Intermediate Novel Analysis: Thank You, Mr. Falker

Intermediate Novel Analysis: Thank You, Mr. Falker

Plot Summary

Trisha is a young girl who loves stories and dreams of being able to read like her older brother and sister. But when she starts school, she realizes that reading is very hard for her. The letters seem to dance around the page, and no matter how hard she tries, she can't make sense of them. As she gets older, her classmates begin to tease and bully her for not being able to read. Trisha starts to feel dumb and alone.

Then, in fifth grade, she meets a new teacher named Mr. Falker. He is kind and encouraging—and he notices that Trisha is struggling. Instead of letting her fall behind, Mr. Falker takes the time to help her. He works with her after school and shows her new ways to learn. With his support, Trisha slowly begins to understand how to read.

By the end of the story, Trisha finally learns to read—and realizes she is not dumb at all. Years later, she remembers Mr. Falker as the teacher who changed her life. The book ends with the author revealing that she was Trisha, and this is her true story.

Main Ideas

Themes: 

  • The Power of Perseverance – Trisha struggles with dyslexia and reading difficulties, but through hard work and the right support, she overcomes her challenges. This teaches the importance of persistence in the face of obstacles.
  • Every Child Learns Differently – Trisha's journey highlights that not everyone learns the same way, and with the right guidance, all children can succeed.

Writing Style: 

  • Personal and Emotional:  The book is based on Patricia Polacco’s own experience with dyslexia, giving it a deeply personal and heartfelt tone. The emotional connection helps readers empathize with the character.
  • Narrative and Reflective:  Told as a narrative, the story flows chronologically and follows Trisha's struggles and triumphs. It includes inner thoughts and feelings, which allow students to understand the character’s emotional journey.
  • Rich Language:  Polacco uses vivid imagery and expressive language. Words like "tormented," "golden honey," and "blurted" help build mood and character.
  • Dialogue-Driven: Conversations between characters, especially between Trisha and Mr. Falker, reveal important turning points and highlight the role of supportive adults.

Educational Value:

  • Social-Emotional Learning (SEL):
    • Empathy for students who struggle with reading
    • Understanding bullying and its impact
    • Recognizing the power of encouragement

Literacy Connection:

  • The book offers a powerful read-aloud for discussing reading difficulties, especially dyslexia.
  • It encourages students to talk about their own learning challenges in a safe way.

Model for Writing Personal Narratives:

  • It’s a strong mentor text for showing how real-life experiences can be turned into meaningful stories.

Text Complexity Map

Title: Thank You, Mr. Falker Author: Patricia Polacco
Publisher: Philomel Books Publication Date: 2012 Pages: 40
Genre: Narrative (Linear)

Text Description Recommended Grade Levels
Thank You, Mr. Falker has a text complexity suitable for upper elementary students (grades 3-5) but can be adapted for grade 2 reading levels with scaffolding, as it is considered a "complex text" due to its deeper themes, emotional depth, autobiographical nature, and rich language that requires inference and personal connection to understand fully. While its simpler vocabulary and shorter sentence structures make it accessible for younger readers to comprehend on a basic level, its profound message about learning disabilities, perseverance, and gratitude provides a significant challenge for developing a deeper understanding and making those personal connections. Grades 3-5.
Quantitative Measures of the Text:
Range:
420L-820L
 		Associated Band Level:
The text is associated with the higher end of the 2-3 band; however, the levels of meaning make the text more challenging.

Qualitative Measures of the Text
Levels of Meaning/Purpose: Moderately Complex

  • Central themes include overcoming learning challenges, bullying, perseverance, and the impact of a caring teacher.

  • The message is accessible to young readers, but the emotional weight adds complexity.

Structure: Moderately Complex

  • Follows a clear chronological structure (Trisha’s early childhood through fifth grade).
  • Contains a reveal at the end—that Trisha is the author—which adds a layer of meaning.
  • Use of flashbacks and emotional pacing enhance depth but are easy to follow.
Language Clarity and Conventionality: Moderately Complex
  • Sentence length and vocabulary are moderately complex.
  • Some figurative and emotional language may challenge younger readers.
  • Mix of simple narrative and emotionally rich, descriptive language.
  • Some figurative language (e.g., “letters dancing on the page”) that may need explanation.
  • Authentic dialogue supports comprehension but requires inference.

Knowledge Demands:  Moderate Complexity

  • Requires some understanding of school dynamics, learning disabilities (like dyslexia), and bullying.
  • Background knowledge about how reading develops may support deeper understanding.

 

Reader and Task Considerations:

Perfect for building empathy and connecting to personal experiences.
Useful for teaching:

  • Theme
  • Character development
  • Narrative structure
  • Point of view

Ideal for read-alouds, book clubs, or SEL-focused lessons at the beginning of the year. 

 

Mentor Text Teaching Points

Reading Skills:

  • Character change over time
  • Recount the story and determine the central message — perseverance, kindness, and the power of a caring teacher.
  • Explore perspective - Trisha (a struggling reader) and Mr. Falker (a supportive mentor).
  • Character responses - how Trisha and Mr. Falker responded to classmates treatment of Trisha

Writing Skills:

  • Use the text as a model for descriptive language and emotional writing
  • Use of adjectives to show emotion
  • Using quotation marks to highlight feelings and emotions
  • Write their own short, powerful sentences that show feelings

Language, Grammar & Conventions:

  • Focus on quotation marks: how Palacco uses dialogue to reveal feelings and relationships.
  • Study of adjectives and descriptive phrases that show emotions (e.g., “smug faces,” “darkness closed in”).
  • Sentence structure: examine how longer sentences build tension and emotion, while short sentences emphasize key ideas.

    • Ex: “She fumbled with the book. She tried to open it. But the letters looked like squiggly lines, and her throat tightened, her eyes filled with tears, and the page began to swim.”

    • Patricia Polacco strings together multiple phrases with commas and conjunctions. This longer structure mirrors Trisha’s rising panic and frustration.

Vocabulary:

  • struggled
  • determination
  • humiliation
  • perseverance
  • mentor
  • ridicule 
  • encouraged

Mentor Sentence:

“She didn’t want to show them she couldn’t read. She was too ashamed.”

  • Teaching Points:
    • Explore strong verbs (show, read).
    • Notice how short sentences express emotion and hesitation.
    • Model sentence combining: Trisha didn’t want to show her classmates that she couldn’t read because she was too ashamed.
    • Students can write their own short, powerful sentences that show feelings.

Check out our other teaching literacy book recommendations for elementary and middle school.

 

Back to blog